The Diamond Discovery Hub and its suggested Diamond OA criteria for journals

Authors

Abstract

Although Diamond Open Access is gaining momentum as a more equitable, fair, inclusive publishing model, there is no universal definition yet of Diamond OA journals. Most prevalent is defining them by zero APC (article processing charges). There’s widespread understanding that absence of APC’s is not enough and that Diamond OA journals should be owned by scientists, academic institutions or research infrastructures and be operated professionally, based on values of research integrity. Thus, Diamond OA is considered to be a positive alternative to economic distortions parts of the open access publishing market display. The DIAMAS and CRAFT-OA projects introduced operational criteria to identify Diamond OA journals. They are required to enable binary decisions of journals classifying as Diamond OA or not within the Diamond Discovery Hub (DDH), a registry for such journals launching by the end of 2025. DDH will be a responsive, scalable platform with SEO-friendly UI, based on an editorial model including trusted data sources of Diamond OA journals on one side and a DDH editorial team on the other. The editorial team will be volunteers, organised along the emerging system of Diamond Capacity Centres and a central Diamond Capacity Hub. Trusted sources will mostly be European institutional publishing service providers (IPSPs). The DDH will support decision making of authors, funders or institutions and bring more visibility and recognition to Diamond OA journals and the Diamond OA model in general. Therefore, inclusion criteria have to be based on observable data points and be as unambiguous and transparent as possible. They are:
1. use of persistent identifier
2. being a scientific journal
3. immediate Open Access with open licences
4. no fees
5. open to all authors within a journal’s scope
6. community-owned
While criteria 1 and 3 are machine-observable data points and for 2, 4, and 5 approved practices exist, criteria 6 on (scientific) community ownership is challenging to base binary decisions on. If parameters of judging “community owned” are set too wide, the rigorousness of such a collection is watered down with too many questionable entries. If set too narrow, the DDH would risk excluding scientific journals identifying with the overall goals of Diamond OA but failing to meet minor aspects of “community owned”. We’d like to facilitate a community effort in developing flexible, transparent parameters for criteria 6. These parameters will help in two ways: journals identifying with values and ethics of Diamond OA find guidance in how to express this in an observable manner while clear parameters enable the volunteers’ work within the DDH editorial team.
We propose a 90-minute workshop to jointly work on the mentioned parameters of criteria 6 around community-ownership. To give participants a hands-on experience we’ll introduce the DDH’s current alpha-version system and our planned editorial model.

Author Biographies

Margo Bargheer, University of Göttingen

Margo is a trained graphic designer and M.A. in social anthropology and media studies. She is head of the electronic publishing team at Göttingen University library which includes the University Press, the OJS platform, several repositories and open access and open science awareness activities on campus. Margo coordinates the CRAFT-OA consortium with 23 European partners and is convinced that Diamond OA is the right way to move forward.

Hanna Varachkina, University of Göttingen

Hanna Varachkina has an academic background in Linguistics, English, and Romance Philology, with research experience in Computational Literary Studies at the University of Göttingen. Since 2014, she has been working at the Lower Saxony State and University Library. Currently, she is a task lead in the CRAFT-OA project and serves as a product owner of the Diamond Discovery Hub.

Malte Dreyer, University of Göttingen

Malte Dreyer studied Philosophy and Literature at the Universities of Kiel and Marburg as well as Library and Information Science at the Humboldt University of Berlin and has been working at the Lower Saxony State and University Library since 2019. His work focuses on the areas of Teaching Library, Open Access and Open Science and Policy Research. Malte Dreyer is currently working in the PALOMERA project and is active in analyzing and indexing policy documents, formulating recommendations and conducting surveys. 

References

Published

2024-09-26

How to Cite

Bargheer, M., Varachkina, H., & Dreyer, M. (2024). The Diamond Discovery Hub and its suggested Diamond OA criteria for journals. Septentrio Conference Series, (1). Retrieved from https://septentrio.uit.no/index.php/SCS/article/view/7810